Sunday, November 18, 2007

Google's Paid Search vs. Organic Results – A Rickety Wall of Separation

This is your SiteProNews/ExactSeek Webmaster Newsletter!
To drop your subscription use the link at the bottom of this message.

   Learn Something Useful - Visit SiteProNews!

  Webmaster Software     Webmaster Resources     Link to SPN     Top SEO Tools     Blog Search     Website Templates 

  Advertise Archives Contact Us Privacy Statement SPN Blog Home SEO News Forums

NOV. 19,  ISSUE #1021

Web Search

Blog Search
   Add a Blog
Search 15,000+ Blogs
Grab a Blog RSS Feed
Blog Express for RSS Feeds
SiteProNews Blog
Read daily blog posts in the SiteProNews Blog by two of the Web's top writers, Jim Hedger and Jerry Bader.

Tools & Services

Webmaster Tools
   Web Page Analyzer
   Meta Tag Generator
   Keyword Popularity Tool
   Link Popularity Checker
   Search Engine Submitter
   Internet Tools Directory
   Site Resource Directory

SEO-News Forums
Join the SEO-News Forums to post comments, articles and tips or learn from SEO experts.
Forum Posts
Yahoo 247
Google 2035
SE Tips 279
Link Exchanges 370
General Discussion 220
Join the SEO-News Forums
ExactSeek Toolbar
Get the toolbar with spyware scanning, webpage keyword analysis, web search on multiple meta engines, popup-blocking, Alexa site ranking, word highlighting, auto-upgrade and erase browser cookies.
Traffïc Exchanges
Get Frëe Traffïc for Your Site with these Traffïc Exchanges:



Site of the Day
The Blog Herald is a premium source of blog and blogging related news for bloggers that focuses on the different facets of blogging. A combination blog and blog news magazine.

Does your web site qualify as a SPN Site of the Day? Webmaster resource sites can apply via email:

App of the Day
Keyword Analyzer 1.0 (961 KB) is a useful keyword generator that can quickly create lists of keywords from a single word or phrase, show keyword search popularity and the number of competitors for those keywords in Google, Yahoo and MSN. Freeware for Windows 98/ 2K/ XP/ 2K3/ Vista.

If you have a Webmaster App that you would like listed on the SPN site, send us an email with details to:

Must Read Ebooks
SPN offers one of the best eBook libraries on the Web. Our current selection includes Commercial and over 183 Frëe eBooks.

Authors can submit eBooks to SiteProNews via email:

Link to SPN
Link your site to SiteProNews, the newsletter and resource site for Webmasters.

Or, Add SPN to your site with just 2 lines of Javascrípt code. Top content for your site without any of the work.

Visit our SPN Promotion Partners page. Some great sites have opted to support the SiteProNews newsletter.

SPN Partners
UmbrellaNews - The Web's most comprehensive news site. Stories updated every 7 to 10 minutes.

SubmitPlus - Promote your site to 110 search engines... Frëe!

Template Monster - The Web's number one website templates are available for immediate download.

Online Site Builder - Providing one step point and clíck web site creation!

Web-Source - Your Guide to Professional Web Site Design & Development. - A directory of programming resources. - A search engine where you can review and subscribe to thousands of IT newsletters.

Frëe Alexa Toolbar - An indispensable tool for web professionals, providing Traffïc Data, Site Stats, and Contact Info for all the sites you visit!.

NewWebDirectory - A new internet web directory of professionally reviewed web sites providing both frëe and paid site submission.

FreeWebMonitoring - Monitor your web site's availability 24 hours a day, 7 days a week with ínstant email alerts and weekly web site performänce statistics. - A new social content website similar to Digg. Submit original content or articles and news items that you believe are newsworthy. - Useful gadgets and widgets for your blog or website. Enhance any web page with just 2 lines of code.

Top 10 Exposure - Forget PPC. Get Google-Type ads for $3 - $4 per month and top 10 exposure across 225+ search engines & web directories. - Provides a directory of trusted, reliable and credible websites based on a unique credibility scoring system


Submit Plus
Blog Search
Web Position
Alexa Toolbar
Top SEO Tools
Website Builder
Top 10 Exposure
$100 Free Traffíc
SiteProNews Blog
WebMaster Radio
Website Templates
Search Engine Tool

Top Webmaster Headlines

Breaking Blog News

Google's Paid Search vs. Organic
Results – A Rickety Wall of Separation

By Scott Buresh (c) 2007 Medium Blue

"Chinese Wall - The ethical (not physical) barrier between different divisions of a financial (or other) institution to avoid conflict of interest..."

"While Google nevër sells better ranking in our search results, several other search engines combine pay-per-click or pay-for-inclusion results with their regular web search results."
Google's Webmaster Help Center FAQ

"NO pay for inclusion, and a complete separation of the search index part from the money part."
Google Chief Engineer Craig Neville-Manning, Search Engine Strategies 2004

Take Submission Monster for a Test Drive!

The good people at Google have long maintained that there is a Chinese Wall between paid search results and organic results – that is, the department responsible for advertising is completely separate from the department responsible for organic search engine placement. The company insists that Google Adwords is a completely separate entity than the Google search engine, and nevër the twain shall meet. This all sounds very good, in theory. But do they live up to this ideal in practice?

You don't hear Google talking much about Chinese Walls these days. This is certainly in part because they have had great difficulty gaining traction in the literal and very competitive Chinese market (headlines such as "Google Hits Chinese Wall" or even "Google Advance Halted at Great Wall of China" were commonplace). But might there be other, more nefarious reasons? Is there a reason why we hear less and less from Google about the virtual wall that separates paid search results from organic search engine placement?

  What Is Google Really Doing for Its Big Spenders?

It has long been rumored that Google will provide technical assistance in achieving better organic search engine placement to those who spend more for paid search results. I know for certain that these rumors are true in at least two instances. In fact, I actually have the minutes from one of these technical assistance meetings after the company met with Google engineers. While the identity of these two companies is irrelevant, suffice to say that they are companies that you have almost certainly heard of and that they spend millíons of dollars on paid search words each year.

To be fair, based on the meeting minutes I have, the advice that the engineers gave to the company does not include anything groundbreaking. It is mostly common sense advice that a good search engine optimization firm already knows about organic search engine placement and other issues, and much of it is already covered in the publicly-available Google Webmaster Guidelines. This, however, is beside the point. Google has obviously decided that it must provide perks to its big paid search spenders to keep them happy (or rather, happy enough to not pull their advertising). Clearly, one of these perks is access to Google engineers and the ability to glean information about organic search engine placement, a luxury that smaller advertisers do not enjoy.

Your Vote Counts!

  Organic Search Engine Placement for Sale – The New Google Reality?

From a business perspective, this makes perfect sense, of course. Big-dollar advertisers make up the bulk of Google's revenue for paid search, and any intelligent business will take whatever steps they deem necessary to hold on to their most valuable customers. This is why larger advertisers already have a designated account representative from Google. I am willing to bet that this perk was not Google's idea. Rather, it almost certainly stemmed from the sense of entitlement that those spending large sums on paid search felt and the fact that technical help with their organic search engine placement is what they demanded.

Unfortunately, this reality leaves an advertiser with a small budget for paid search at a disadvantage. If Google is willing to provide this secret perk to larger advertisers now, what might they do in the future? Provide price breaks to larger paid search spenders? Raise the minimum monthly spend to squeeze out smaller companies and please the larger ones? It certainly has the potential to become a slippery slope, and I am interested to see where it goes next.

One final point – since Google is willing to give advice about organic search engine placement to companies that spend a great deal of monëy on Google advertising, is the phrase "While Google nevër sells better ranking in our search results..." truly accurate? I suppose this is open for interpretation. It may be technically true, but offering advice regarding organic search engine placement straight from the horse's mouth in exchange for millíons of dollars in monëy for paid search results isn't far from selling rankings, in my opinion.

Forget Expensive PPC Advertising - There is an Alternative!


Please don't get me wrong – I still believe that Google is the best search engine out there, I greatly admire the way that they are continually reinventing themselves, and I think they are still the target for those seeking the most benefit from organic search engine placement. They have the folks in Redmond constantly guessing and always three steps behind, and I love how they have started from humble beginnings to take on one of the biggest corporations in the world (and consistently win). I simply believe that they have played the underdog, anti-corporate card for too long, and that even if it has not outlived its usefulness, it has outlived its truthfulness. Google is now a huge multinational corporation that answers to its shareholders. To pretend anything otherwise is silly, but it seems that, for now at least, the charade will continue.

Google's overriding principle, one that they have been happy to espouse to the media, has long been "Don't Be Evil." Whether they still adhere to this principle since they have become a public company is another question that is open for interpretation. If you are a smaller advertiser and feel that Google's favoritism toward larger paid search customers regarding organic search engine placement is evil, it probably seems as though the "Don't Be Evil" principle no longer applies. You may conclude that the principles of "Don't Be Evil" and "Keep Shareholders Happy" are mutually incompatible, and that the latter has gained the upper hand.

About The Author
Scott Buresh is the CEO of Medium Blue, which was recently named the number one search engine optimization company in the world by PromotionWorld. Scott has contributed content to many publications including Building Your Business with Google For Dummies (Wiley, 2004), MarketingProfs, ZDNet, Organic Rankings, WebProNews, DarwinMag, SiteProNews,, and Search Engine Guide. Medium Blue serves local and national clients, including Boston Scientific, DS Waters, and Wake Forest University Baptist Medical Center. Download Medium Blue's latest exclusive whitepaper, "Adding Search to Your Marketing Mix," for more insight.

Printer Friendly Version of this Article

Recommended Webmaster Articles

Social Media Outreach 101: 5 Tips for Integrating into Communities
As our society continues the rapid shift to digital communities, forums and blogs have earned a prominent place in the Internet marketing spotlight.

Eleven Things That Define What A Quality Link Is
In any link building campaign, its not just about the quantity of links you get but more importantly the quality of the link. Many newcomers to SEO think, as long as its a one way link or has high page rank, then its a great link, but there are so many other elements to consider before judging whether a link is good for your site or not.

Destination Marketing: SEM Without Compromise
...Destination Marketing is SEO and SEM without compromising rankings for conversions or conversions for rankings.

Internet Forums - Six Ways To Avoid Disaster
Internet Forums are highly popular, they cater for all tastes and deal with every topic imaginable. People visit Internet forums for a variety of reasons, the most common being the search for information or entertainment.

Need Content for Your Website - has 603,000+ Articles
Add a GoArticles RSS feed or Javascrïpt feed in seconds.

GoArticles has introduced an
Article Rating System - Read, Then Rate!

Webmaster Resource Sites & Services

Top SEO Tools - A suite of the best online submission, reporting and SEO Tools available. Sign up for a frëe tríal.

Add Me! - a pioneer in search engine submission, and the most popular. They provide frëe submission and paid submission.

Google Ranking Secrets Revealed! Boost Your Google Ranking, Get More Orders, And Make More Monëy!

Build Your Traffíc with ABCSearch
Get $100 of FR-E-E qualified Visitors. Sign-up today and we'll match any initial deposit up to $100. Geo-targeting, full reporting and one clíck results!

Recommended Webmaster Tools & Services

Net Research Server (NRS) - a complete search engine solution for sites wanting to host entire web search, industry specific search, site search, or directory search. NRS also enables users to submit listings, create alerts, and organize bookmarks.

Select from 1000's of Quality Templates
Need a new site look? Select from thousands of professional designs for a fraction of web design costs. Get a multi-page website up in just a few hours.

Build a Business Website in Under 5 Minutes.
Over 172,000 people just like you have used Exact Websites to build professional websites, complete with web pages, photo albums, email, links and 27 other features without ever having built a website before.

WebPosition helps you maximize your site's search engine visibility by providing a complete SEO solution including rank reporting, keyword research, page optimization and submission. Download a frëe demo today!

Have an Opinion on Today's Article?
Post Your Comments in the SEO-News Forums
Sign Up for FR-E-E and Participate



SiteProNews - The Net's most widely read Webmaster newsletter

You are currently signed up to spn-aesop as:
To not receive further mailings, send a blank email to

Jayde Online, Inc.
Suite 238, 23-845 Dakota Street
Winnipeg, MB R2M 5M3
(c) Copyright 2007 All rights reserved


Post a Comment

<< Home